Pros and Cons of Testosterone Replacement Therapy

Doctor writing notes while a patient sits opposite, discussing the pros and cons of testosterone replacement therapy

The pros and cons of testosterone replacement therapy (TRT) depend on one result: total testosterone under 300 ng/dL plus symptoms. In the 5,246-man TRAVERSE trial, TRT improved sexual activity, mood, energy and anemia. TRT also lowers sperm production, raises red blood cell counts and usually continues long term. This guide weighs each pro against its matching con.

Key Takeaways

  • Benefits of testosterone replacement therapy include better sexual desire, mood, energy, lean mass, bone density and anemia correction.
  • Downsides include lower sperm count, higher red blood cell counts, acne, breast tenderness and possible sleep apnea worsening.
  • Candidates need symptoms and two low morning blood tests, with total testosterone under 300 ng/dL.
  • Prostate cancer, breast cancer, hematocrit above 54% and plans for children are reasons to avoid TRT.
  • Monitoring starts 3 to 6 months after the first dose, then continues yearly.

What Are the Pros and Cons of Testosterone Replacement Therapy?

The pros and cons of testosterone replacement therapy are five benefits against six downsides for men with confirmed low testosterone. The benefits are sexual desire, mood and energy, lean mass, bone density and anemia correction. The downsides are fertility loss, high red blood cell counts, skin and breast changes, sleep apnea, ongoing treatment and monitoring.

Every item on both lists depends on a true deficiency, so a root-cause workup through hormone care plan comes before any decision. The table below sets the benefits beside the downsides.

Pros and cons of testosterone replacement therapy by body area
AreaProConEvidence
Sexual healthHigher desire; sexual activity up 0.49 acts per day at 6 monthsErectile function did not improve versus placeboTRAVERSE 2023
Mood and energyModest gains in mood and energyNot a depression treatment; no gain in cognition or sleep qualityTRAVERSE 2024
BloodAnemia corrected in 41.0% versus 27.5% at 6 monthsHematocrit above 54% in 22% versus 1% on placeboTRAVERSE, T4DM
BodyLean mass and spine bone density rise; fat mass fallsSmall effects; no proven strength or fracture benefitAAFP 2017
FertilityNoneSperm count falls and the testicles shrinkCleveland Clinic
Skin and breastNoneAcne, oily skin, breast tenderness in 10% to 25%Cleveland Clinic, PMC
CommitmentSymptom relief for as long as treatment worksOngoing treatment and yearly monitoringCleveland Clinic, AAFP

The table shows that each benefit carries a matching trade-off. The graphic below turns the same list into a quick side-by-side view.

Side-by-side panel of testosterone replacement therapy benefits and downsides for men with confirmed low testosterone

Who Is a Good Candidate for Testosterone Replacement Therapy?

A good candidate for testosterone replacement therapy is a man with low-testosterone symptoms and two confirmed low morning blood tests. A Houston Methodist urologist defines low testosterone as total testosterone under 300 ng/dL. Hypogonadism means that low result plus symptoms, which separates it from a number alone.

Nearly 40% of men over 45 have low testosterone, according to the same urologist, so testing matters more than guessing. The Endocrine Society 2018 guideline asks for repeat measurement, and free testosterone is checked when the total sits near the lower limit. Our overview of TRT for men covers the basics.

Diagnosis and safety screening follow four steps before the first dose.

  1. Review symptoms such as low libido, fatigue, low mood and loss of muscle.
  2. Run two morning total testosterone tests on separate days.
  3. Check free testosterone when the total sits near the lower limit.
  4. Order hemoglobin, hematocrit, liver tests, luteinizing hormone (LH), prolactin and prostate-specific antigen (PSA).

Cleveland Clinic lists the same baseline labs, and the results decide which benefits and risks apply next.

What Are the Benefits of Testosterone Replacement Therapy?

The benefits of testosterone replacement therapy are better sexual function, lean body mass, bone mineral density, mood, energy and sense of well-being. Cleveland Clinic names these six gains for men with low testosterone. Trial evidence is strongest for sexual desire and anemia, and weaker for strength and thinking.

The next sections grade each benefit by its evidence, starting with sex drive.

Does Testosterone Replacement Therapy Improve Sex Drive and Erections?

Testosterone replacement therapy improves sex drive in men with low testosterone, but it helps erections less. The TRAVERSE Sexual Function Study followed 1,161 men with low libido. Sexual activity rose 0.49 acts per day at 6 months. The gain was 0.47 acts per day at 12 months.

The same study found better sexual desire but no better erectile function than placebo. A review from the American Academy of Family Physicians (AAFP) found libido benefits in 13 of 23 trials. Eight trials showed none and two were mixed. The AAFP also notes that testosterone has no evidence of helping erections in men with normal levels.

Desire is only one of several symptom changes, and mood follows it closely.

Can Testosterone Replacement Therapy Improve Mood and Energy?

Testosterone replacement therapy can modestly improve mood and energy in men with low testosterone. A TRAVERSE analysis found modest but significantly greater gains in mood and energy than placebo. Cognition and sleep quality did not improve.

Depressive symptoms were present in 2,643 of the 5,204 men, or 50.8%. The AAFP review calls the earlier depression trials mixed, so TRT is not a depression treatment. Energy changes also link to the blood count, which brings up anemia.

Can Testosterone Replacement Therapy Correct Anemia?

Testosterone replacement therapy can correct mild anemia in men with low testosterone. In a TRAVERSE anemia trial, anemia corrected in 41.0% of testosterone-treated men versus 27.5% on placebo at 6 months. At 12 months the figures were 45.0% and 33.9%.

Testosterone stimulates red blood cell production, which explains the benefit and also the risk covered later. Muscle and bone are the next body systems to compare.

TRAVERSE trial results for testosterone therapy: sexual activity gain, anemia correction and major cardiac events

The graphic above shows the three TRAVERSE results used in this section.

Does Testosterone Replacement Therapy Build Muscle and Bone?

Testosterone replacement therapy raises lean mass and spine bone density, but the strength gains are small. The AAFP review reports that lean mass rises and fat mass falls, with small effect sizes. Studies have generally not shown better strength or physical function.

Bone density rose at the lumbar spine in middle-aged men, and in the spine and hip in older men. The AAFP review found no evidence of fewer fractures or falls. Body fat is the next question men ask.

Can You Lose Belly Fat on Testosterone?

Yes, testosterone lowers fat mass modestly, but it is not a weight-loss drug. A meta-analysis of 59 randomized trials found fat mass fell and lean mass rose without a change in body weight. Waist size and body mass index (BMI) did not change significantly either.

In the T4DM trial of 1,007 men with larger waists, every participant also followed a lifestyle program. Diet and movement remain the weight-loss foundation, and clinical nutrition supports that part.

Set Up An Appointment

What Are the Downsides of Testosterone Replacement Therapy?

The downsides of testosterone replacement therapy are skin, breast, fluid, sleep, fertility and blood changes. Cleveland Clinic lists eight side effects and two lab changes, including smaller testicles and higher PSA. Many are manageable with monitoring, yet some require stopping.

The common side effects and lab changes are listed below.

  • Acne or oily skin.
  • Ankle swelling from mild fluid retention.
  • Prostate stimulation that can cause urinary symptoms.
  • Breast enlargement or tenderness (gynecomastia).
  • Worsening sleep apnea.
  • Smaller testicles and lower sperm count.
  • Skin irritation from gels or patches.
  • Higher PSA and higher red blood cell counts.

Gynecomastia or breast pain occurs in 10% to 25% of men on TRT, per a PMC review. The side effects of testosterone replacement therapy are rechecked at every follow-up visit. Our page on TRT side effects covers each one in detail. Fertility is the downside that raises the next question.

Does TRT Affect Fertility?

Yes, TRT affects fertility because testosterone therapy suppresses sperm production. Cleveland Clinic says TRT causes the testicles to stop working, so sperm count drops. The AAFP lists a desire for fertility as a relative contraindication.

Men who plan biological children should avoid TRT, and Cleveland Clinic adds that repairing fertility afterward can be slow and expensive. A fertility specialist should guide any plan to conceive. Red blood cell counts are the next downside.

Can Testosterone Replacement Therapy Cause High Red Blood Cell Counts?

Yes, testosterone replacement therapy can raise red blood cell counts, a condition called erythrocytosis. In the T4DM trial, hematocrit went above 54% in 22% of men on testosterone versus 1% on placebo. Hematocrit is the share of blood made of red cells.

The AAFP says a hematocrit above 54% means stopping TRT, lowering the dose or switching formulations. Thicker blood raises concern for clots, so blood counts are checked at baseline, at 3 to 6 months, and yearly. Heart and prostate safety come next.

Is Testosterone Replacement Therapy Safe for the Heart and Prostate?

Testosterone replacement therapy was not linked to more major heart events in the TRAVERSE trial, but it raised other risks. Major cardiac events occurred in 7.0% of men on testosterone versus 7.3% on placebo. Atrial fibrillation, acute kidney injury and pulmonary embolism were more common with testosterone.

The prostate substudy found high-grade prostate cancer in 5 of 2,596 men on testosterone and 3 of 2,602 on placebo. That gap was not statistically significant. Men with prostate cancer should still avoid starting TRT.

Who Should Avoid Testosterone Replacement Therapy?

Men with prostate cancer, breast cancer, a hematocrit above 54% or a PSA above 4 ng/mL should avoid testosterone replacement therapy. The AAFP lists these as absolute contraindications. Cleveland Clinic adds a recent heart attack or stroke, untreated sleep apnea and plans for children.

Relative contraindications call for a specialist's judgment.

  • Baseline hematocrit above 50%.
  • Desire for fertility.
  • Severe lower urinary tract symptoms.
  • Uncontrolled heart failure.
  • Untreated obstructive sleep apnea.

Men with any of these conditions should talk to their doctor before starting or stopping any hormone.

Which Form of Testosterone Is Most Effective?

No single form of testosterone is most effective, because the AAFP says no formulation has superior clinical effects. Route, side effects and cost drive the choice. Testosterone products are Schedule III controlled substances.

The table below compares the common forms by schedule and main trade-off.

Common testosterone forms by schedule and main trade-off
FormScheduleMain trade-off
Skin gelDailyCan transfer to partners and children through contact
InjectionEvery 1 to 2 weeks; some long-acting forms every 10 weeksLevels can peak and dip between doses
PelletsEvery 3 to 6 monthsRequires a procedure to implant under the skin
Oral pillTwice dailyOlder forms raised liver concerns; newer forms do not, per Houston Methodist
Nasal gelThree times dailyHighest dosing frequency of any form
Skin patchDailySkin rash is common, so sites rotate

Gels carry a transfer risk to partners and children, which pushes some men toward injections. The form changes how steady the levels stay, which affects the timeline.

How Long Does Testosterone Replacement Therapy Take to Work?

Testosterone replacement therapy takes a few weeks before mood and body changes appear. Providers typically check levels about 30 days after the first dose, according to Cleveland Clinic. Results vary from person to person.

The TRAVERSE sexual activity gain showed at 6 months. Cleveland Clinic says a provider may recommend stopping when symptoms do not improve after 3 to 6 months. The low level may not have been the cause.

How Long Can a Man Stay on TRT?

A man can stay on TRT for as long as it relieves symptoms and causes no health problems. Cleveland Clinic calls TRT a long-term therapy, since levels return to baseline after stopping. The body then needs time to restart its own production.

The AAFP monitoring schedule keeps long-term use safe: a check 3 to 6 months after starting, then yearly. Targets sit at the midnormal range of 400 to 700 ng/dL. A urology referral follows a PSA rise above 1.4 ng/mL in 12 months.

Timeline of testosterone replacement therapy monitoring from baseline labs to the 3 to 6 month check and yearly visits

The graphic above lays out the monitoring timeline. Cost, shots and lab visits make the worth question fair.

Is Testosterone Replacement Therapy Worth It?

Yes, testosterone replacement therapy is worth it for men with confirmed hypogonadism and symptoms, and not worth it for normal levels. The FDA approves it for low testosterone from testicle, pituitary or brain disorders, not for age-related decline. Age-related use is off-label.

The American Urological Association (AUA) advises against TRT for erectile dysfunction with normal testosterone. Weighing the risks and benefits of testosterone replacement therapy starts with a confirmed diagnosis. Testosterone replacement therapy pros and cons differ for each man. Lifestyle changes come first, per Houston Methodist. A fuller plan for hormonal health care addresses sleep, stress, weight and nutrition alongside any prescription.

What Else Should You Know About Testosterone Therapy?

Why Are Doctors Hesitant to Prescribe TRT?

Doctors are hesitant to prescribe TRT when risks are unclear, and the 2015 FDA advisory flagged possible cardiovascular risk. The AAFP notes that long-term data were uncertain then. TRAVERSE later reported its heart results, and monitoring remains required.

What Are the Signs You Need Testosterone?

The signs you need testosterone are low libido, fatigue, low mood, lost muscle and extra body fat. Only blood tests confirm a deficiency, since these signs overlap with other conditions. Our guide to low T symptoms explains when to test.

Will Testicles Grow Back After TRT?

Testicles can recover after TRT stops as natural production restarts, but the recovery time varies. Cleveland Clinic says the body needs time to restart testosterone production. A doctor can check whether levels have recovered.

Does Testosterone Therapy Affect Sleep?

Testosterone therapy can worsen sleep apnea in some men. An 18-week trial of 67 obese men with severe apnea found worse oxygen levels at 7 weeks, recovered by 18 weeks. Anyone with loud snoring or daytime sleepiness should look at sleep disorder care first.

What Medications Cannot Be Taken With Testosterone?

Diabetes medicines, blood thinners such as warfarin, propranolol and steroids such as prednisone interact with testosterone. Cleveland Clinic lists these interactions for testosterone injections. Herbs and supplements can also interact, so herbal safety deserves a review with the prescriber.

Can Women Use Testosterone Therapy?

The evidence supports testosterone therapy in women only for low sexual desire after menopause. The 2019 Global Consensus names that as the one evidence-based indication. Our page on female testosterone therapy covers the details.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a 1500 Testosterone Level OK?

No, a total testosterone of 1,500 ng/dL sits far above the 400 to 700 ng/dL goal range. The AAFP says values outside that range need a dose adjustment. A man seeing this result on treatment should contact his prescriber.

What Is Bioavailable Testosterone?

Bioavailable testosterone is the portion of testosterone the body can use, meaning free testosterone plus testosterone loosely bound to albumin. The Endocrine Society advises checking free testosterone when total testosterone sits near the lower limit. A prescriber orders the right test.

Do You Gain Weight on TRT?

No, TRT does not cause weight gain in studies. A 59-trial meta-analysis found no significant change in body weight, waist size or BMI. Fat mass fell and lean mass rose.

Can You Stop Testosterone Replacement Therapy Once You Start?

Yes, a man can stop testosterone replacement therapy at any time with his provider's guidance. Cleveland Clinic says levels return to baseline afterward. Natural production takes time to restart.

How Does Cutler Integrative Medicine Support Men With Low Testosterone?

Cutler Integrative Medicine supports men with low testosterone by finding root causes and working alongside the prescribing physician. We help men weigh the pros and cons of testosterone replacement therapy with their doctor. We do not prescribe testosterone. Our role is testing, nutrition, naturopathic hormone care and lifestyle planning.

Dr. Doug Cutler, ND, reviews hormone levels through blood work, including saliva adrenal testing. The plan looks at stress, gut health, thyroid function, toxin exposure, sleep and nutrition. Those factors can lower testosterone, and addressing them may support symptom relief. We also use biointelligent lab testing where it adds useful detail.

Men in Bingham Farms and across Metro Detroit can also meet with us by telemedicine. Call (248) 663-0165 to book a visit. Learn how Cutler Integrative care fits around the treatment from your doctor.

Read Dr. Cutler's Complete Bio!

You May Also Like

What Our Patients Say About Their Healing Journey

“Dr Cutler is simply wonderful. He has done more for my overall health than any doctor I've ever seen. He not only gives you a plan to help you to better health, he educates you so you recognize the start of issues so you can address them before they become bigger problems. I've never felt so healthy!”

- April C.

View More Reviews

The information and services offered go hand and hand with my family goals. Dr Cutler listens and because he is all about preventing vs just medicating it lets us know we went to the right place.

- Gail M.

View More Reviews

Dr. Cutler has done an amazing job at helping me with a medical condition and helping me to find relief. He is very personable and open minded, give him a visit for sure!

- Maggie H.

View More Reviews